James alternates a bit, when putting on games in the legendary wargames room, between made-up scenarios and historical refights. We have therefore replayed numerous battles from the Punic Wars, the Italian Wars, the Seven Years War and so on, none of which I had ever heard of before let alone knew anything about. Even when we got on to World War II we only ever fought Sidi Rezegh. However, now he has painted up a very large number of Napoleonic units I'm in with a shout. And so we are half way though Vimeiro, sort of. As you will know if you have read his blog he has given the French a chance by allowing all their attacks to go in at once. It doesn't seem to have done them any good, and nor has my knowledge done me any good, but I shall wait until we've finished the game to explain why. What I would say is that his mechanism for forcing the French to attack in the right locations if not at the right times is quite inspired.
The big question was what changes he would have made to the rules, and he didn't disappoint. As a quick summary:
- The movement rules are far better and lifted directly from Black Powder
- The morale rules are much better, but I still don't really like them
- The skirmisher rules are certainly the operationally slickest that we have tried, which is a result in itself.
- And for no reason that I could establish he has changed all the names of the cards, resulting in much confusion.
At least you are playing a game, which has to be a good thing! I will check out James blog as I would be interested to see a few pics of the action.
ReplyDelete