"Françaises, Français, le Général de Gaulle est mort. La France est veuve. En 1940, de Gaulle a sauvé l’honneur. En 1944, il nous a conduits à la Libération et à la victoire."
That was how President Georges Pompidou announced the death of Charles de Gaulle in November 1970. The particular aspects of de Gaulle's career to which he referred have recently been the subject of a massive, two-part biographical epic directed by Antonin Baudry.
I haven't seen much mention of these films in the wargaming blogs which I read, but then it's fair to say that I didn't see many people at the screenings I attended either. That's a shame because I thoroughly enjoyed them and would strongly recommend them to those with both an interest in the history of the second world war and with several hours to spare. At its heart is, as Peter Bradshaw of the Guardian put it, a bromance between Simon Akbarian's General and Simon Russell Beale's Churchill; both of whom are excellent by the way. The films are quite traditional in tone, and those who like me grew up watching British war films on the TV on a Sunday afternoon will find it all a bit nostalgic, at least once you look past the colour, the CGI (Bir Hakeim is given a lot of screen time) and the fact that about two thirds of it is in French. I learnt a lot from it; I really wasn't previously aware just how often de Gaulle fell in and out of favour with the Allies.
The Americans, especially Roosevelt, don't come out of it particularly well, although Eisenhower at least is allowed an element of personal growth. Another film featuring Ike is Pressure (Monty also pops up in both) which I found entertaining enough. The author of the original play and co-scriptwriter here, David Haigh (*), manages to deal very well with the awkward fact that we all know what's going to happen. The only points of inherent tension are whether the invasion will be postponed from its original date of June 5th and whether it will succeed the following day in the brief window of respite that has been forecast; so no tension at all really. Despite that one does feel engaged throughout. I mentioned to my companion for the evening (**) afterwards that some liberties seem to have been taken for dramatic effect, and she nodded knowingly and said she had never believed in 'that Irish woman', looking rather sceptical when I maintained that Kay Summersby definitely existed. It's another film that allows Eisenhower some personal growth.
* You will recall Haigh as the bridegroom, Bernard, in the second of the Four Weddings.
** I had been oddly unable to entice anyone to accompany me to six hours of grand-scale European historical blockbuster in a foreign language.

No comments:
Post a Comment